By: William C. Head, Criminal Defense Attorney Atlanta GA and ABA Board-Certified DUI Attorney
Birchfield v. North Dakota, Decided on June 23, 2016. Docket Number No. 14–1468, impact in Georgia.
Opinion of the United States Supreme Court from an appeal of a North Dakota Supreme Court implied consent refusal case – Landmark US Supreme Court decision on implied consent laws in certain states that criminalize a refusal to be tested, by a breath alcohol test or a DUI blood test.
Georgia law does not criminally punish a person for refusing to be tested if lawfully arrested for DUI, but imposes a harsh, one-year total DUI administrative license suspension for refusing to be tested. Birchfield was one of three appellants, all of whom made challenges to their state laws imposing criminal punishment for a person’s refusal to submit to a blood test or breath test when requested under implied consent laws in those states.
In summary, the High Court in Birchfield made several clear rulings regarding states that have passed implied consent laws that make a driver’s refusal to be tested a crime.
Breath alcohol tests – Are considered a lawful search for breath alcohol test evidence of the crime of DUI, when the officer gathers sufficient evidence of IMPAIRMENT by alcohol to make a lawful arrest. No warrant is required in breath alcohol test cases and Georgia’s current ALS penalties (for refusal to submit, or for taking the test and being over the legal limit) are allowed.
Blood tests for alcohol or for other drugs – A search warrant is required unless exigent circumstances exist (e.g., the person was unconscious and unable to respond). An officer need not even read implied consent if the driver voluntarily CONSENTS to a blood test.
Whether after being told the implied consent warning after a DUI arrest or just in a conversation between the officer and the detained driver, before the arrest, actual consent must be proven. This issue is determined in each case by a totality of the circumstances, which requires a judge to hold a pre-trial hearing when the DUI defense lawyer files a motion to exclude a blood test.
Partial inaccuracy of the wording of the implied consent warning is a factor in determining the driver’s voluntariness of consent. Additionally, Birchfield clearly held that “motorists cannot be deemed to have consented to submit to a blood test on pain of committing a criminal offense” by refusing to be tested.
Some people foolishly try to self-assess their chances of winning a DUI in GA. The operable word here is “FOOLISHLY.” Just reading TRUE DUI case histories with: (1) BAC levels triple the legal limit, (2) a DUI refusal and failing all three NHTSA field sobriety tests, or (3) another drunk driving case report of a DUI checkpoint with an Intoxilyzer breath test double the legal alcohol limit, from two of our previous criminal trials will dissuade you from thinking that you have no chance to beat a DUI in court.
After being arrested for DUI in GA, some people are so depressed that they dwell on their mistake the night before, and not on beating the criminal charges. Fear of the unknown can be a powerful enemy. Our DUI lawyer partners WELCOME comparing criminal attorney comparisons. For example, our law firm has three different law book authors, which is unique in Georgia and possibly in all of America.
A successful defense record for all Atlanta DUI attorneys in the law firm must include possessing the ability to neutralize field sobriety test evidence and finding ways to eliminate breath alcohol test results, especially where the “number” is in excess of the legal alcohol limit. Plus, knowing the LAW is critical, and this entails our DUI attorneys being familiar with every prior appellate decision on Georgia DUI laws and especially Georgia implied consent law.
Drugged driving cases have grown by 100% in the last 15 years. Sleep driving DUI cases, after taking prescribed medications for insomnia or pain management are up by 400%. Plus, a conviction for DUI-drugs has more devastating DUI penalties in Georgia that a DUI-alcohol case, due to more severe loss of driving privileges and other loss of entitlements (e.g., loss of the GA Hope Scholarship due to a “drugs” conviction).
Each DUI attorney in our law office possesses special training on debunking “drug recognition” officers’ training and roadside tests like the “modified Romberg test” and the less-extensive ARIDE protocols require that our criminal defense lawyers know how to challenge a GBI blood alcohol or drugs test. Each of our Atlanta lawyers is an INSTRUCTOR in the three NHTSA standardized field sobriety tests (SFST), which exceeds the training of most police officers making arrests for DUI in Georgia.
The best DUI lawyers in Atlanta, Georgia will offer you a FREE attorney consultation, explain how their criminal defense attorneys review your DUI case facts and implement a game plan for winning. Our three Georgia Super Lawyers aggressively represent clients accused of committing crimes through filing and arguing suppression motions. Limit your search to a lawyer for DUI who has achieved legitimate legal industry excellence attorney ratings, and who possesses a track record of proven drunk driving defense results on knowing how to beat a DUI. If our law firm has the RIGHT criminal defense attorney for you, ask our law office about our DUI attorney payment plans.
Call our DUI attorneys NOW, 24-7, for an initial criminal case review and to obtain FREE legal advice: 404-567-5515, or email our criminal justice lawyers.